- Total episodes: 49
- The infamous SOS Fantomes debate
- In 2009, Greg watched the wrong movie.
- Doug Nagy did not enjoy Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
- There was 1 Top 5 segment and 1 Versus segment
- Reed Farrington was a guest on 8 episodes
- Frank was a guest on 3 episodes
- Doug Nagy was a guest on 2 episodes
- Singe, Wintle and Goon were guests on 1 episode
|201||January 4, 2009||Doubt|
|202||January 11, 2009||No feature review.||Most anticipated movies of 2009.|
|203||January 19, 2009||Paul Blart: Mall Cop||Jay and Sean recap their Sundance trip.|
|204||January 26, 2009||Paranoid Park|
|205||February 2, 2009||Taken||Greg recaps his "Epic" trip to Montreal.|
|206||February 8, 2009||Miracle at St. Anna|
|207||February 16, 2009||Friday the 13th (2009) / Waltz With Bashir||Top 5: Most romantic horror movies|
|208||February 22, 2009||No feature review||Live pre-Oscar show.
Versus: Mickey Rourke vs. Robert Downey Jr.
Guests: Reed Farrington and Frank
|209||March 1, 2009||Outlander||Greg watches the wrong movie.
Guest: Doug Nagy
|210||March 8, 2009||Watchmen / Pontypool||Greg talks about going to see Nickelback|
|211||March 16, 2009||The Last House on the Left (2009)||Guest: Wintle|
|212||March 22, 2009||Knowing / I Love You, Man|
|213||March 30, 2009||12 Rounds|
|214||April 6, 2009||Anvil! The Story of Anvil|
|215||April 13, 2009||Observe and Report|
|216||April 19, 2009||Crank 2: High Voltage||Most influential movies of last decade.|
|217||April 27, 2009||Fighting / Fast and Furious / Monsters vs. Aliens||Hot Docs 2009 preview.|
|218||May 4, 2009||X-Men Origins: Wolverine|
|219||May 11, 2009||Star Trek||Guest: Reed Farrington.|
|220||May 24, 2009||Terminator Salvation|
|221||June 1, 2009||Up / Drag Me to Hell|
|222||June 14, 2009||The Taking of Pelham 123 (2009) / The Hangover / Land of the Lost|
|223||June 22, 2009||Year One||The guys discuss disliking French on their DVD and Blu Rays leading to the infamous "SOS Fantomes" debate.
|224||June 28, 2009||Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen||Doug destroys Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
Guest: Doug Nagy.
|225||July 6, 2009||Public Enemies / Not Quite Hollywood|
|226||July 13, 2009||Bruno|
|227||July 21, 2009||Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince / The Hurt Locker|
|228||July 27, 2009||Big Fan / Ong-Bak 2||Jay is away.
Guest: Reed Farrington.
|229||August 3, 2009||Funny People / The Girlfriend Experience|
|230||August 9, 2009||G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra / Orphan|
|231||August 16, 2009||District 9||Guest: Reed Farrington|
|232||August 23, 2009||Inglourious Basterds|
|233||August 30, 2009||No featured review||Summer movie recap.
Fall TV Preview #5
|234||September 7, 2009||Extract / Gamer / Halloween II (2009) / The Perfect Getaway||The guys complete a drive-in marathon|
|235||September 14, 2009||No featured review||TIFF recap part 1. Guest: Reed Farrington. Greg is away.|
|236||September 20, 2009||No featured review||TIFF recap part 2|
|237||September 27, 2009||The Informant!|
|238||October 5, 2009||Zombieland||Jay doesn't like "the rules" of Zombieland.|
|239||October 11, 2009||Capitalism: A Love Story|
|240||October 26, 2009||Where the Wild Things Are|
|241||November 2, 2009||Paranormal Activity / The House of the Devil||Greg is away.
Guest: Reed Farrington.
|242||November 9, 2009||The Box|
|243||November 15, 2009||2012||Guest: Reed Farrington|
|244||November 22, 2009||A Serious Man||Greg is away
|245||November 29, 2009||Fantastic Mr. Fox||Greg's first Jackson Square stories. The guys talk about Black Friday deals.
|246||December 6, 2009||Steven Seagal's Lawman||Discussion: The films of Wes Anderson. Singe was scheduled to be on this episode, but couldn't make it.|
|247||December 14, 2009||The Cove||The idea of making episode 250 a clip show is discussed.|
|248||December 20, 2009||Avatar||Guests: Reed Farrington and Singe|
|249||December 29, 2009||Sherlock Holmes|